Best Exercise Mat for Floor Workouts: Thickness Decides Nothing

One mat here warns that your shoes may tear it and says it is designed for barefoot exercise. Another puts the words shoe-friendly in its own title. Those are two different products for two different hobbies, sitting in the same search, and the word on the box that everybody actually shops on is thickness, which settles neither.

CAP Barbell Mat Mat Half Inch Thick with Carrying Strap in TealAmazon Basics Half Inch Extra Thick Exercise Pilates Mat in BlackGruper Non Slip Pilates Mat in Matcha Green and Blackbemaxx Gym Mats Set 18 Piece EVA Interlocking Foam Floor TilesCAP Barbell Folding Exercise Mat 2 Inch Thick in BlackRetrospec Solana Pilates Mat 1 Inch Thick with Nylon Strap in BlackGymCope Large Extra Thick Exercise Mat for Home Workout

At a glance

Product Size and surface Price tier Link
CAP Barbell Mat 68 x 24. The shortest mat here Budget CAP Barbell Mat Mat Half Inch Thick with Carrying Strap in Teal
Amazon Basics 1/2″ 74 x 24. The longest, and it calls itself cushy Budget Amazon Basics Half Inch Extra Thick Exercise Pilates Mat in Black
Gruper 6mm 72 x 24. Warns that shoes will tear it Budget Gruper Non Slip Pilates Mat in Matcha Green and Black
bemaxx Tiles 18 sq ft at 3 ft wide. Half again a stretching mat Budget bemaxx Gym Mats Set 18 Piece EVA Interlocking Foam Floor Tiles
CAP Folding 2″ 72 x 24, two inches, and it connects to more Mid-range CAP Barbell Folding Exercise Mat 2 Inch Thick in Black
Retrospec Solana 1″ 72 x 24. The only mat here calling itself firm Mid-range Retrospec Solana Pilates Mat 1 Inch Thick with Nylon Strap in Black
GymCope Large Up to 12 by 6 feet. Shoe-friendly, in the title Premium GymCope Large Extra Thick Exercise Mat for Home Workout

How to choose

Thickness without firmness tells you nothing

A thick mat protects your knees and a thick mat also lets you sink into it, and those are the same property working for you and against you. Soft and thick means you wobble in anything standing. Firm and thick means you get the cushioning without the swim. Exactly one listing here uses the word firm, and it is the one selling a full inch. Everyone else offers extra thick, high density or cushy, and none of them publishes a density figure of any kind.

One listing tells you it is soft, and it is the real one

The mat here describing itself as cushy also says its foam offers stretchability and springs back into shape. Stretchy is exactly what you do not want under a plank: a surface that gives sideways as you press into it. That is not a criticism of the mat, it is a description of what half an inch of soft foam is for, which is lying on. Read the adjectives rather than the millimeters and the category sorts itself.

Shoes are the real question and two listings answer it

The search says floor workout, which for most people means shoes. One mat here states plainly that it is designed for barefoot exercise and that your shoes or your pet’s paws may tear it. Another puts shoe-friendly in its own title and says use with or without shoes. Everything in between is a stretching mat that has not thought about it. If your workout involves trainers, a jump rope or a dumbbell you might drop, that single line matters more than any other spec here.

Twenty-four inches is not a floor workout

Almost every mat here is 24 inches wide, because that is the stretching-mat standard, and stretching is done standing on a strip. Lie down and put your arms out and you are on the carpet. The two products here that take the search literally are wider: one gives 18 square feet as interlocking tiles at three feet across, half again a stretching mat, and the other starts at six feet by four and goes to twelve by six. Length varies from 68 to 74 inches, which matters if you are tall.

Every foam mat smells, and one seller says so

Unroll a new foam mat and your room will know about it for a couple of days. One listing here tells you that in advance, calls the odor harmless, and says to air the mat for a day or two before using it. Nobody else mentions it, and every one of them will do it. That is a small piece of clarity and it is the sort of thing that predicts the rest of a listing.

Name the material, not the mood

Chemical claims here run the full range. One mat says it is free of ten harmful phthalates, and names the standard as 10P, plus lead and mercury. Another says free of phthalates, heavy metals and latex. A third says BPA-free. And one says it is made with premium friendly material, which costs more to make and is safer than traditional non-green PVC and EVA, without ever saying what its own material actually is. Better than two things it is not, is not a material.

Look at how many results are one product

Ten results here are six products. One mat appears three times in three colors with identical bullets and an identical price. Another appears twice, in black and blue, two cents apart. That is worth knowing before you conclude a brand dominates the category, and it is worth knowing when you are comparing prices: the color you like is the same mat as the color you do not.

CAP Barbell Mat

CAP Barbell Mat Mat Half Inch Thick with Carrying Strap in Teal

The cheapest mat here, and a straightforward half inch of high-density padding at 68 by 24 inches with a carrying strap. It gives the same figure two ways, half an inch in the title and 12mm in the bullets, which agree, and it is specific about what the padding is for: spine, hips, knees and elbows. Note the length. At 68 inches it is the shortest mat on this page, six inches under the longest, and if you are much over five foot eight your head or your heels will find the floor.

Pros:

  • The lowest price on this page
  • Publishes its thickness consistently in both units
  • Names what the padding protects: spine, hips, knees, elbows
  • Carrying strap included; wipes clean

Cons:

  • 68 inches; the shortest mat here by six
  • High-density claimed with no density figure
  • 24 inches wide; a narrow strip

Best for: a short mat for a short person, cheaply.

Check price on Amazon

Amazon Basics 1/2″

Amazon Basics Half Inch Extra Thick Exercise Pilates Mat in Black

At 74 by 24 by half an inch it is the longest mat in this search, and length is the specification nobody thinks about until they lie down and their heels are on the carpet. Textured for traction, with an elastic strap for rolling and carrying, and it publishes its dimensions to the decimal. It is also refreshingly plain about what it is: cushy, with foam that stretches and springs back. That is a mat for lying on rather than balancing on, and it says so without being asked.

Pros:

  • 74 inches; the longest mat on this page
  • Real that it is cushy and stretchy
  • Textured surface for traction; elastic strap
  • Publishes full dimensions

Cons:

  • Stretchy foam moves under a plank
  • Names no material and no chemical exclusions
  • 24 inches wide

Best for: floor work, from the longest mat here.

Check price on Amazon

Gruper 6mm

Gruper Non Slip Pilates Mat in Matcha Green and Black

The most useful warning in this search sits in its care instructions: designed for barefoot exercise, and your shoes or your pet’s paws may tear the mat. That is the sentence that should be on half the products here. It also publishes both of its options properly, at 6mm and 2.6 pounds or 8mm and 3.1 pounds, both 72 by 24, with a sticky texture on both sides and a double layer against tearing, plus a strap and a bag. Its material is described only as premium friendly.

Pros:

  • Warns plainly that shoes will tear it
  • Publishes thickness and weight for both options
  • Non-slip texture on both sides; double layer
  • Strap and storage bag both included

Cons:

  • Never names its own material
  • Barefoot only; not for a shoes-on workout
  • 6mm is thin for knees on a hard floor

Best for: barefoot floor work, which is what its own listing describes.

Check price on Amazon

bemaxx Tiles

bemaxx Gym Mats Set 18 Piece EVA Interlocking Foam Floor Tiles

Not a mat but a floor: eighteen interlocking EVA tiles at 12.6 inches square, plus edge pieces, covering roughly six feet by three. That three feet of width is half again what every stretching mat here offers, and it is the number the phrase floor workout actually implies. It is highly compressed foam, waterproof, insulating and noise-dampening, which makes it as much about protecting the room below as the knees above. It publishes tile size, count and total area, and you can buy more.

Pros:

  • Three feet wide; half again a stretching mat
  • Publishes tile size, count and total area
  • Expandable; add sets for a bigger floor
  • Waterproof, insulating and noise-dampening

Cons:

  • 0.4 inches; thin for knees or tumbling
  • Tiles separate under heavy sideways load
  • Not portable in any meaningful sense

Best for: covering a floor rather than lying on a strip.

Check price on Amazon

CAP Folding 2″

CAP Barbell Folding Exercise Mat 2 Inch Thick in Black

Two inches of high-density foam, which is four times the common half inch here and puts it in different territory: tumbling, karate, gymnastics, the things where you land rather than lie. It folds on built-in nylon handles so two inches of foam can be carried and stored, and hook and loop closures join several together into a proper floor. Its chemical claim is the most specific on this page, naming ten phthalates as a standard alongside lead and mercury, which is why it is comfortable calling itself a kids’ mat.

Pros:

  • Two inches; genuine impact absorption
  • Names ten phthalates, lead and mercury as excluded
  • Folds on nylon handles; stores compactly
  • Joins to more mats for a larger floor

Cons:

  • Two inches is unstable for standing work
  • Still only 24 inches wide
  • High-density claimed with no figure

Best for: tumbling and landing, not balancing.

Check price on Amazon

Retrospec Solana 1″

Retrospec Solana Pilates Mat 1 Inch Thick with Nylon Strap in Black

The only listing in this search that uses the word firm, and that word is what makes an inch of thickness a good idea rather than a wobble. Firm and thick gives you the cushioning under knees, hips and hands without sinking; soft and thick gives you a mattress. It is 72 by 24 by 1 with a nylon strap, free of phthalates, heavy metals and latex. It is also the only listing here that admits a new foam mat smells, calls it harmless, and tells you to air it for a day or two.

Pros:

  • The only mat here describing itself as firm
  • A full inch of cushioning without the sink
  • Free of phthalates, heavy metals and latex
  • Real about the new-mat smell and how to clear it

Cons:

  • 24 inches wide; still a narrow strip
  • Publishes no density figure to back up firm
  • Says nothing about shoes either way

Best for: knees and hips, without losing your balance.

Check price on Amazon

GymCope Large

GymCope Large Extra Thick Exercise Mat for Home Workout

The only product here that answers the search on both counts. It is shoe-friendly and says so in the title, so a jump rope, a pair of trainers and a dropped dumbbell are all within scope, where a stretching mat’s own listing warns shoes will tear it. And it is genuinely large, in six sizes from six by four feet up to twelve by six, so two people can work out or one person can move. Seven millimeters of high-density foam, and mats combine for more area.

Pros:

  • Shoe-friendly, stated in the title
  • Six sizes, from 6×4 feet up to 12×6
  • Built for cardio, jump rope, weights and dance
  • Combines with more mats for a bigger area

Cons:

  • By far the highest price here
  • 7mm; thinner than several cheaper mats
  • Not something you roll up and carry to a class

Best for: a real workout, in shoes, with room to move.

Check price on Amazon

The verdict

Thickness is the number on the box and it decides nothing on its own, because soft and thick means you sink and firm and thick means you do not, and only one listing here says which it is. The two questions that actually sort this page are whether you will be wearing shoes, which two listings answer and the rest ignore, and whether 24 inches of width is a floor workout, which it is not.

Best overall: Retrospec Solana 1″. It is the only mat in this search that calls itself firm, and that word is the difference between an inch of useful cushioning and an inch of wobble. You get the padding under knees, hips and hands without the surface swimming when you press into it. It is free of phthalates, heavy metals and latex, comes with a nylon strap, and its listing is the only one straight enough to warn you that a new foam mat smells and to air it first.

Best value: Amazon Basics 1/2″. The longest mat on this page at 74 inches, which is six inches more than the shortest and the difference between your heels being on the mat and on the floor. Half an inch of textured foam with an elastic strap, at a price nothing else here approaches for that length. Its own bullets tell you it is cushy and stretchy, so take it as a mat for lying on rather than balancing on and it is exactly right.

Best premium: GymCope Large. The only product here that reads the search properly. Shoe-friendly is in its title, which matters enormously when another mat on this page warns that trainers will tear it, and it comes in six sizes up to twelve feet by six, so you can actually swing a rope or move sideways. Everything else is 24 inches wide because that is what a stretching mat needs, and a floor workout is not stretching.

FAQ

How thick should an exercise mat be?

Thickness alone will not tell you. Soft and thick means you sink and wobble; firm and thick gives cushioning without the swim. One listing here says firm, one admits it is cushy and stretchy, and four say high-density without publishing a density.

Can I wear shoes on a stretching mat?

One listing answers directly: it is designed for barefoot exercise, and your shoes or your pet’s paws may tear it. Another puts shoe-friendly in its title. If your workout involves trainers, that line matters more than the millimeters.

Why are they all 24 inches wide?

Because that is the stretching-mat standard, and stretching is done standing on a strip. Lie down with your arms out and you are on the carpet. The two products here that take floor workout literally are three feet and six feet wide.

Does length matter?

If you are tall. Mats here run from 68 to 74 inches, and that six inches is whether your head and heels stay on. Only some listings publish it, and the shortest is also the cheapest.

Why does my new mat smell?

They all do. One listing here says so, calls the odor harmless, and tells you to unroll the mat and air it for a day or two. Nobody else mentions it, and every foam mat on this page will do it.

This article may contain affiliate links; see our Affiliate Disclosure.

 

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to our RSS feed!
Best Exercise Mat for Floor Workouts: Thickness Decides Nothing
Scroll to top